A faculty member is presenting at a conference in Nashville on Thursday and Friday. She’d like to fly home Monday instead of Friday night, partly to see her sister and partly because the Monday return is $140 cheaper. Her approver forwards the request to you with one line: “Is this allowed?” Somewhere in your inbox sits last year’s internal audit finding, noting that personal travel wasn’t well documented.

You’ve probably heard the rule everyone repeats: if personal days outnumber business days, the university can’t pay the airfare. Some institutions have written that into policy as a formal day count. When I’ve asked travel managers where the rule comes from, the answer is usually “the IRS, I think,” followed by a pause. That pause is worth examining. The gap between what the IRS says and what our policies say creates friction for travelers whose trips cost the university nothing extra, and it doesn’t fix the audit finding.

The IRS rule is fuzzier than the policies built on it

For travel within the United States, the governing rule is Treasury Regulation §1.162-2(b). Transportation to and from a destination is a business expense if the trip is primarily for business. Whether it is depends on the facts and circumstances, and the time spent on personal versus business activity is “an important factor.” It is not a formula. The regulation’s own example of a trip that’s primarily personal is lopsided: a week of business followed by five weeks of vacation at the same destination.

The day-counting mechanics many policies borrowed live in a different part of IRS Publication 463: the section on travel outside the United States, which comes from a different regulation (§1.274-4). That section has its own rules, including a provision that treats most employees traveling under a reimbursement arrangement as having no substantial control over the trip. One large public university in Texas follows that logic. It treats foreign trips with personal days as entirely business for airfare, capped at a business-only quote, while applying a strict day count to domestic trips. Its policy is also governed by a state travel statute your state may not have.

There’s one more wrinkle. Publication 463 is written for taxpayers deducting their own expenses. A university isn’t deducting anything. Its question is whether a reimbursement meets the accountable plan rules, which means it has a business connection. Reimbursing airfare on a trip that is genuinely primarily personal isn’t a crime. It’s taxable wages, and that is a payroll question. It isn’t a reason to run every traveler through a calculator.

Three things to check in your own program

Start by pulling last year’s trips that included personal days and sorting them by personal days minus business days. I’d bet most are a weekend or two or three days tacked onto a conference. A handful will look like the regulation’s week-and-five-weeks example. That handful is your real exposure, and it’s small enough for a person to review.

Next, look at how you capture personal dates. If it’s a free-text comment field, a few years ago I would have said your auditor can’t test it and neither can you. That has changed. If your organization uses AI, export the reports with that text field alongside the true travel start and end dates, then have the AI read the personal-days text and put it into two columns, a start date and an end date, in a format you define. Voilà, you have what you need. It can also flag trips that cross a Saturday night. If you are building a system from scratch, put structured personal start and end dates on the travel request or expense report, and this analysis gets much easier.

In SAP Concur, as an example, an audit rule can then flag only the trips where personal time clearly dominates and send those to your tax or payroll office for a decision. Everyone else moves on.

Finally, read your policy for a cost-comparison requirement. If the extension doesn’t raise the fare, there’s nothing to compare. If it does, reimburse the lesser of the actual fare and a business-only quote taken at booking. Ask any travel manager about midweek fares: a Saturday-night stay is often cheaper than flying Monday through Thursday. It may be the most effective travel policy most universities never wrote.

What good looks like

At an institution that has sorted this out, the policy says plainly what the university pays on personal days: nothing. No hotel, no meals, no car. Personal dates live in structured fields that can be reported on. Approvers understand that they are approving a business purpose, not judging someone’s weekend. The genuinely lopsided trips have a defined path to the people who decide taxability, and the audit finding closes because the documentation exists.

It also recognizes who’s traveling. Most faculty travel a few times a year at most. When they’re in Orlando or Lisbon to present their work, staying two extra days is not abuse. It’s the rare chance to make a long flight worth it, and sometimes the only time they’ll see family that year. A rule that treats that as a compliance risk costs more in goodwill than it saves in airfare.

I’m not a tax attorney, and your tax office should have the final word on taxability at your institution. But this is exactly the kind of policy question I help untangle before it turns into a Concur configuration, an audit rule and a support ticket.

Sources

U.S. Department of the Treasury, 26 CFR §1.162-2, “Traveling expenses,” via Cornell Legal Information Institute (law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.162-2).

Internal Revenue Service, Publication 463 (2025), Travel, Gift, and Car Expenses, Chapter 1 (irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p463.pdf).

University of Houston, MAPP 04.02.01A, “Travel Paid from State-Appropriated Funds,” last revised October 9, 2025.

University of Houston Office of Finance, “Personal vs Business,” AP Travel, page updated May 13, 2025.

About the author. Elizabeth Downs is Founder & Principal of Clay Downs Consulting, a travel and expense consulting firm built exclusively for higher education. She has led 65+ T&E implementations across 85+ colleges, universities and academic medical centers. More about Elizabeth · LinkedIn